Case

Kalundborg: Industrial Symbiosis - Waste makes resource

Industrial Symbiosis is a collaborative enterprise in which the by-products of one industry become valuable resources for one or several other industries. The overall result is of direct economic benefit to the companies involved and widespread environmental benefit to the surrounding region. By 1998, Kalundborg could already boast that internal collaboration between industries had amounted to savings of 160 million dollars since the project’s outset.


Kalundborg is a medium-sized town on the north-west coast of Zealand, 105km from Copenhagen, home to 16,500 residents and host to the world's most well known example of industrial ecology; Industrial Symbiosis. The motivation for exchange arose in the early 1970s from a mutual effort to reduce costs by seeking income-producing uses for "waste" products. Gradually, those involved realized that a carefully managed exchange of energy and materials could enable mutual economic benefit whilst reducing the environmental impact of large industrial operations.

Today, Kalundborg’s Industrial Symbiosis comprises eight core companies; DONG Energy Asnæs Power Station, Statoil-Hydro Refinery, Gyproc A/S, Novo Nordisk, Novozymes, recycling company RGS 90 A/S, waste company Kara Noveren I/S and Kalundborg Municipality. Each company is bound to each other via an intricate network of flows; flows of steam, gas, water, gypsum, fly ash and sludge.

Ideas on the industrial symbiosis, November 20, 2008 by Timothy Terway, Flickr Creative Commons

Excess steam from Asnæs Power Station is exported to Kalundborg’s combined district heat and power supply and to both Statoil and Novo Nordisk who use it as an incoming heat source before exporting it back to Asnæs as condensed steam for cooling the plant. Gyproc A/S receives excess gas as an input energy source from Statoil- Hydro Refinery and industrial plaster as an input material source from Asnæs power station. Calcium and recycled treated waste water are added to the sulphur extracted from the flue gas at Asnæs to form industrial plaster: SO2+CaCO3+½O2+2H2O=CO2+CaSO4•2H2O (Sulphur + Calcium + Oxygen + Water = Gypsum).

Insulin production at Novo Nordisk A/S releases material which is exported to surrounding farms as pig fodder. A by-product of the yeast fermentation process is converted into yeast slurry. This replaces approximately 70% of the soy proteins in traditional feed mixes. Novo Nordisk A/S adds sugar, water and lactic acid bacteria to the yeast in order to make it more attractive to the pigs.

Cradle-to-cradle principles encourage us to make waste into food and fuel just as nature does. Kalundborg’s Industrial Symbiosis shows the benefit to both economy and environment which can occur when such principles become reality.

Kalundborg moves into the future

Kalundborg is now setting its focus on renewable energy and resources. Asnaes power station has recently pledged a 50% switch to renewables by 2020, with ‘block 5’ (generation from coal) due to close, and biomass replacing its current quota of raw material.

A pioneering enterprise lead by Inbicon and supported by the network facilitating EU project, Cluster Biofuels Denmark (CBD), is pursuing how the symbiotic model can enable a significant increase in effectiveness when generating energy from biomass. For example, surplus steam from the Asnaes plant can be used to better prepare the straw for the energy generation process. With straw as the input material, the outputs are bioethanol for fuel (for transport etc.), C5-molasses as animal feed and solid biofuel for application in both domestic and district heat and power generation. Inbicon’s plant can also be adapted in order to receive other forms of biomass material; corn stover, grasses, bagasse, household waste etc.

Flow diagram of the Industrial Symbiosis in Kalundborg, 1995, courtesy of the Kalundborg Centre for Industrial Symbiosis

Javascript is required to view this map.

Comments

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <ul> <ol> <li> <h3> <hr> <hr/> <p> <img> <br> <br/> <br /> <table> <tbody> <tr> <td> <sub> <sup>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Sorting

Sorting

Making the Change

Key Learning Points

The basis of the Industrial Symbiosis cooperation in Kalundborg is open communication and mutual trust between the partners. Business to business relationships occur on a voluntary basis, but are encouraged, facilitated and managed by the Kalundborg Symbiosis Institute.

As Inbicon and other biomass initiatives join the network, the introduction of new raw materials with an organic base launches a whole new range of valuable by-products. These are of particular interest for medical and agricultural industries which both form a vital base of the Danish economy. Such new developments are due to feed the original Industrial Symbiosis project with new life and rebrand Kalundborg at the centre of ‘Biocon Valley’. CBD will be an intricate part of this development by bridging interests between companies, research institutions and the municipality.

The key to symbiotic success lies in increasing the combined effectiveness of all processes rather than only focusing on the individual efficiency of one single process. The total amount of waste generated can then be decreased and the total output of energy and resource material increased. Such developments are seen as significant steps towards achieving economic viability for clean energy production.

Process

1961
Kalundborg Industrial Symbiosis’ first pipes are connected

1970s
Relationships formalized between the initial core industries

1976
Novo-Nordisk plant initiates material flows to match evolving energy flows at Kalundborg

1981
Asnæs supplies excess steam, first, to Kalundborg district heating system, next, to Statoil and Novo Nordisk

1990s
A team of ‘Earth Day’ students map the network of by-product exchanges with yarn and present to the plant managers!

1992
Asnæs begins replacing fuel sources; surplus refinery gas instead of coal

1993
60 million dollar investment in infrastructure (transport, energy and materials) produces $120 million in revenues and cost-savings

1995
extent of materials and energy exchange amounts to 3 million tons per year

1998
160 million dollar savings recorded due to industry collaboration and exchange

2008
introduction of biomass via Cluster Biofuels Denmark and Inbicon

Facts

City Facts

Country: Denmark
City: Kalundborg
Population: 16.489 (2009 est.)
GDP (per capita): $37,200 (2008 est.)

Source: Wikipedia, CIA World Factbook 

Media

YouTube

Industrail Ecology,  Leiden-Delft Industrial Ecology MSc programme.

Google Map

a:2:{s:4:"zoom";s:1:"7";s:7:"latlong";s:34:"56.601838481314694,10.074462890625";}


Dig this

Case: Sutton: BedZED - Leading the way in eco village design

Beddington Zero Energy Development (BedZED) is UK's first eco-village. Here, sustainability has been considered in nearly every design feature.

Fact/Quote

“Fertilisers are the largest single source (38%) of emissions from agriculture. Livestock is the second largest source of emissions, accounting for 31% of agriculture emissions.”
Stern Review, 2006

Back to top