Windmills at Middelgrunden, Copenhagen, 5 August 2007, By Andjohan, Flickr, Creative Commons

Case

Copenhagen: Cities can run on wind energy

The Danish Government is aiming to turn 50% of Danish electricity consumption into offshore wind power by 2030. In 2000, the city of Copenhagen took part in a large offshore wind farm project called Middelgrunden two kilometres off the city's coastline. The project was to produce energy for the city. Although wind power produced locally in Copenhagen is for national consumption this case shows that cities can be visionary and produce energy themselves.


In 2000, the city of Copenhagen took part in a large offshore wind farm project two kilometres off the city's coastline. The project is based on a partnership between the municipality and local shareholders.
Wind energy is not the energy source that immediately springs to mind when thinking about renewable energy in cities. Few cities have enough space within their area to build large wind farms. It is more common to find small wind turbines on suitable locations or even on buildings.

The wind farm ‘Middelgrunden’ consists of a slightly curved line of 20 turbines, each with a rotor diameter of 76 m and a generator size of 2 MW. Wind turbines are expensive to build, whereas the operating costs are low. Denmark tops world consumption of wind power with 22 per cent of its total electrical consumption produced in wind turbines in June 2005. This compares to a mere 6 per cent in neighbouring Germany and 0.5 per cent globally. Middelgrunden does not produce electricity specifically for Copenhagen. The wind power production bought by energy company Dong Energy and sold to national as well as international customers.  

Windmills at Middelgrunden, Copenhagen, 5 Aug 2007, By Andjohan, Flickr, Creative Commons

Denmark was a pioneer in developing commercial wind power during the 1970s. Today almost half of the wind turbines placed around the world are produced by Danish manufacturers, such as Vestas Wind Systems A/S. The Danish government in the 1980s and 1990s was supporting wind energy development. This resulted in a dramatic reduction in the cost of wind-generated electricity. To promote investments in wind power families were offered tax deductions if generating their own energy within their own or the neighbouring municipality. This incentive resulted in the creation of numerous vind power cooperatives. In 2001, more than 100.000 Danish families were members of a vind power cooperative.

Middelgrunden Vindmøllelaug is the largest of its kind in the world with 8.600 owners. Middelgrunden wind power park is 50 % financed by 10.000 stockholders in Middelgrunden Vindmøllelaug and 50 % financed by the municipal energy supplier in Copenhagen, Copenhagen Energy.

“Public resistance against wind turbines in the landscape is and has been one of the largest barriers to the development of wind power – and thus to the development of an environment friendly and sustainable energy supply. This counts both for Denmark and other countries. At the moment, there is though a wide support for wind energy in Denmark” Middelgrunden projektinformation

Javascript is required to view this map.

Comments

50% is a great target, but I wonder why we are not looking at reducing our consumption rather than managing how we supply our demands. By 2030 this will not be nearly good enough. The population will continue expanding and shifting shores. This will place terrible demands that will not support the alternative technology.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <ul> <ol> <li> <h3> <h4> <hr> <hr/> <p> <img> <br> <br/> <br /> <table> <tbody> <tr> <td> <sub> <sup>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Sorting

Sorting

Making the Change

Key Learning Points

Financing a wind farm can be done through private-public partnership

 It is important to ensure ownership to the wind farm among politicians, municipal authorities, energy companies, NGO’s and citizens, in order to secure success

How to

People – potential shareholders, neighbours, interest groups, politicians etc. – must be involved in the relevant parts of the project during the entire process

Problems with acceptance can be helped, if interest groups and authorities are contacted at an early stage

It is essential to disseminate the appropriate information at the right time. Many initial reservations towards the Middelgrunden project were based on fear of the negative impact. Careful information distribution and dialogue assured that the reservations did not develop into serious problems for the project. E.g. the neighbours were invited on a tour to visit a modern wind turbine, which convinced them that noise would not be a problem

Relevant and critical reactions should be taken seriously and it is necessary to adapt the project in order to meet concerns. In the Middelgrunden project, the design of the wind farm was changed. It cost an extra year of planning, but broad local support was accomplished in the end

The Environmental Impact Assessment (VVM) should be taken very seriously, and responses at the hearing have to be taken into account

Large projects need a minimum amount of start up capital – or require a large amount of voluntary work

Facts

City Facts

Country: Denmark
City: Copenhagen
Area: 88.25 km2 (city)
Population: 530, 902 (city, 2010)
Population density: 6,015.9/km2
GDP per capita (country): USD 36,000 (2009 est.)

Source: Wikipedia, CIA World Factbook

Project facts

Wind power in Denmark provided 19,7 % of the nation's electricity in 2007, a significantly higher proportion than in any other country. This compares to a mere 6 percent in neighbouring Germany and 0.5 percent globally.

Percent renewable energy in electricity Consumption in Denmark was 28.5 % in 2005 of which wind power accounted for 18,5 % of this.

The total investment in the project was nearly 45 mio Euro (340 mio DKK)

The Danish Energy Agency granted 680 800 Euro (5,1 mio DKK) to investigate the technical and environmental aspects of offshore wind power. This study analysed the following issues:

  • The risk of leaking debris and metal contamination from the former dumpsite
  • The noise propagation
  • Influence on the free flow of water in The Sound

The operator of the power grid naturally needs other sources than wind power to secure the power supply when there is no wind. When there are strong winds, it must be possible to sell the surplus production. Consequently the power supply can only be based on wind power to some extent. 

Media

YouTube

Gives you a good idea of the size of the mills

Google Map

a:2:{s:4:"zoom";s:1:"9";s:7:"latlong";s:34:"55.67448697232047,12.7056884765625";}


Dig this

Case: Seattle: Water as an urban space maker

Seattle of the USA, is in need of public open spaces that make the city livable, walkable and sustainable. The "Blue Ring" strategy (2002) is a 100-year-old vision and 10-year-long method for accomplishing this.

Fact/Quote

“The great majority of European organisms and ecosystems will have difficulty adapting to climate change”
Climate Change, IPCC 2007

Back to top